trade-thesis-validator
Review daily trade journal entries for thesis completeness. Use when a trader submits a journal entry and needs validation that the thesis meets the minimum standard for entry.
SKILL.mdskills/interactive/.claude/skills/skill-evals-creator/evals/dummy-trade-thesis-validator/SKILL.md
GitHubTrade Thesis Validator
Reviews trade journal entries and validates each thesis against minimum entry standards.
A valid thesis must include
- Strategy tag —
[MR](Mean Reversion) or[MOM](Momentum) clearly stated - At least one indicator value — a specific number for RSI, SMA_20, SMA_50, distance to 52w high/low, or volume trend
- A directional rationale — why the setup justifies entry at this time
Output format
Entry: <ticker>
Result: VALID | NEEDS_REVISION
Reason: <one line — either "Meets minimum standards" or the specific gap>
Rules
- Flag NEEDS_REVISION if any of the three required elements is absent
- NEEDS_REVISION reason must name the specific missing element — not just "incomplete thesis"
- Do not flag NEEDS_REVISION for style or formatting preferences — only for missing required elements
- If the thesis contains a strategy tag but no indicator value, that is a NEEDS_REVISION — "no indicator value cited"