review-02-question-lock

Narrow and lock the scientific question for a medical review. Use when converting a broad topic into PICO/PECO, PCC, or mechanism-focused review questions and choosing a stable manuscript angle.

SKILL.md

GitHub

Review 02 Question Lock

Purpose

Turn a broad direction into a review question that can guide search, screening, evidence synthesis, and writing.

Required Inputs

  • Project brief from $review-01-project-init.
  • User preference on review type if available.
  • Known constraints: deadline, target journal tier, disease area, model system, or clinical population.

Output

Create 01_question_scope/question_lock.md with:

  • One primary question.
  • Up to three secondary questions.
  • PICO/PECO/PCC table when applicable.
  • Inclusion boundary and exclusion boundary.
  • Three candidate titles: conservative, balanced, high-impact.
  • Recommended final choice with rationale.

Completion Gate

Pass only when the final question is narrow enough to generate database-specific search strings and broad enough to support a full review.

Stop Rules

Do not claim novelty. Phrase gaps as "candidate gap requiring literature verification" until search evidence is available.